The Musical Theater participants at OLSH have won or been nominated for the following Gene Kelly Awards.
2023 - Big Fish
- Nominee - Best Scenic Design - Budget Level I
- WINNER! - Nominee - Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
- WINNER! - Nominee - Best Crew/Technical Execution
- WINNER! - Nominee - Best Dance Ensemble
- WINNER! - Nominee - Best Vocal Ensemble
- WINNER! - Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
2022 - Bye Bye Birdie
- Nominee - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
2021 - Working (2012 Revised Edition)
- Nominee - Best Actress - Ellie Troiani
2020 - Seussical
No awards program held.
2019 - Once Upon a Mattress
- Nominee - Best Scenic Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
- WINNER! - Nominee - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Crew/Technical Execution
- Nominee - Best Actress - Alyssa Brinza
- WINNER! - Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
2018 - Beauty and the Beast
2017 - Footloose
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actress - Christina Trocchio
2016 - Thoroughly Modern Millie
- Nominee - Best Scenic Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
2015 - The Addams Family
- WINNER! - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actress - Christina Trocchio
2014 - The Wiz
- Nominee - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
- WINNER! - Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
- WINNER! - Best Scenic Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actress - Ashley Sitarik
2013 - Honk!
- Nominee - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
2012 - How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- Nominee - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Scenic Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Actor - Zander Lyons
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actress - Adrianne Knapp
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actor - Vinnie Smith
2011 - Little Shop of Horrors
- Nominee - Best Costume Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Direction
- WINNER!- Best Lighting Design - Budget Level I
- WINNER!- Best Scenic Design - Budget Level I
- Nominee - Best Actor - Zander Lyons
- Nominee - Best Actress - Adrianne Knapp
- Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
2010 - Once on this Island
- Nominee - Best Choreography
- Nominee - Best Costume Design
- Nominee - Best Direction
- Nominee - Best Ensemble
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design
- Nominee - Best Actress - Kyleigh Taylor
- Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
2009 - Hello Dolly
- Nominee - Best Direction
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design
- Nominee - Best Actress - Caitlin O'Connor
- Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level II
2008 - Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
- Nominee - Best Ensemble
- Nominee - Best Actor - Jeff Markanich
2007 - Working
- Nominee - Best Crew/Technical Execution
- Nominee - Best Ensemble
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actor - Jeff Markanich
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actress - Emily Bull
2006 - Seussical
- Nominee - Best Costume Design
- Nominee - Best Direction
- Nominee - Best Ensemble
- WINNER! - Best Actress: Mallory Praskovich
- Nominee - Best Musical - Budget Level I
2005 - Bye Bye Birdie
- WINNER! - Best Costume Design
- WINNER! - Best Supporting Actress: Mallory Praskovich
- Nominee - Best Musical
2004 - Once Upon A Mattress
- Nominee - Best Scenic Design
- Nominee - Best Actress: Karen Sealy
2003 - The Sound of Music
- WINNER! - Best Scenic Design
- Nominee - Best Musical
2002 - Godspell
- Nominee - Best Costume Design
- Nominee - Best Ensemble
2001 - Anything Goes
- Nominee - Best Choreography
- Nominee - Best Crew/Technical Support
- Nominee - Best Ensemble
- Nominee - Best Lighting Design
- Nominee - Best Actress: Jessica Hortert
- Nominee - Best Musical
2000 - Working
- Nominee - Best Direction
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actress: Lucy Spardy
- Nominee - Best Supporting Actress: Nicole Spardy
- Nominee - Best Musical
1999 - Mame
- Nominee - Best Costume Design
1998 - Bye, Bye, Birdie